Entry: Exploding Liberal Myths 10: The Plame Name Game Tuesday, July 12, 2005



Once again, the Liberal media is trying to ramp up hysteria over the "outing" of Ambassador Joe Wilson's wife, CIA employee Valerie Plame. The problem with their frenzy is that there's no substance to the charge, once all the angry flailing and faux outrage are done with.

Liberals are sacrificing what little credibility they have left with the American people in their desperate attempt to destroy the Bush administration at all costs. To that end, they have continually accused President Bush's advisor Karl Rove of giving Plame's name to the media in order to punish Wilson, after Wilson investigated reports of Saddam's attempt to buy Nigerian uranium and lied about his findings.

Wilson filed a disappointingly neutral report upon his return, but published an editorial stating unequivocally that the British-backed claim was absolutely untrue -- and that President Bush was using it anyway, to create a reason to attack Saddam. However, in his 2004 book, Wilson revealed that "It was Saddam Hussein's information minister, Mohammed Saeed al-Sahhaf, often referred to in the Western press as 'Baghdad Bob,' who approached an official of the African nation of Niger in 1999 to discuss trade -- an overture the official saw as a possible effort to buy uranium." So the uranium buy attempt actually did happen, and Wilson knew about it, but lied about it to try and prevent the liberation of Iraq for political purposes.

In the Liberal version of events, Karl Rove -- a consummately clever political operator by all accounts, except in this story -- revealed Plame's role as a covert agent for the CIA out of sheer vindictiveness. I don't know how that makes any sense, or what end it was supposed to achieve, but somehow it seems perfectly reasonable to Liberals that he would do this. Rove did, in fact, mention that Wilson's wife worked for the CIA to Time reporter Matt Cooper, but never indicated that she had once been a spy. Cooper was not the writer who published her identity -- that was columnist Robert Novak. The problem is that in order to prove Rove did anything illegal, an illegal act has to have taken place.

Knowingly revealing the identity of a covert agent is illegal under the Intelligence Identities Protection Act. If that's what Rove or anyone else did, he ought to be hung out for the crows. (I wonder whether Liberals will wail about such a violation of the Geneva Conventions, as they do when terrorists get too much or too little air conditioning?) In order for Rove (or whoever the source was) to have broken the law, he would have to know and reveal that Plame was a covert operative for the CIA. The problem is... she wasn't one anymore.

Apparently, Valerie Plame ceased to be a covert agent when her cover was blown years earlier. The CIA believed that Aldrich Ames (CIA agent/KGB spy/traitor) revealed her role, along with many other operatives, to the KGB before his arrest in 1994. Plame's former existence as a secret agent became little more than cocktail party chatter with which to thrill the uninitiated. Since her identity was not classified, not secret, and she had not been assigned to duty outside the US in the last five years, revealing her mundane desk job with the CIA was simply not a crime. Lots of people work for the CIA, after all.

What no one talks about is the reason Wilson was picked to go to Niger... the question that originally nagged Novak. In fact, whoever did uncover Plame's involvement in her husband's selection did the country a favor. Plame wanted Wilson to investigate the British claim because of his vocal antipathy to President Bush and his staunch opposition to the overthrow of Saddam Hussein. He was sent not to gather evidence and form a conclusion, but because his conclusion was foreordained. Whoever sent him was attempting to exert an undue influence over America's foreign policy by sending someone who would ignore evidence contrary to his opinion. Do we really want former secret agents playing political games to determine the outcomes of investigations before they're even begun? Investigations the outcomes of which may determine the nation's course in wartime?

Once again, Liberals and their pet Democrats have chosen the wrong hill to die on. While ignoring the real problem we narrowly avoided, they try to whip us into an attack on someone who, even if their accusations are true, commited no crime.

Exploding Liberal Myths 11: Home Spying Hogwash 
Exploding Liberal Myths 9: The Separation of Church and State 
Exploding Liberal Myths 8: The Nazi Meme 
Exploding Liberal Myths 7: Fidel Castro, Demigod?
Exploding Liberal Myths 6: A Less Safe Post-Iraq
Exploding Liberal Myths 5: The Moral United Nations
Exploding Liberal Myths 4: Runaway Global Warming
Exploding Liberal Myths 3: Outsourcing Woes
Exploding Liberal Myths 2: The Eeevil PATRIOT Act
Exploding Liberal Myths 1: Nigerian Uranium  

   8 comments

Sister Toldjah
July 12, 2005   11:13 PM PDT
 
Right on, Cav -I wrote about this issue earlier at my blog as well. It almost seems like "perception has become reality" and we're seeing a mammoth instance of "I've made up my mind, don't disturb me with the facts" rearing its ugly head.
Jamie
July 12, 2005   11:22 PM PDT
 
This Byron York piece is good:

http://www.nationalreview.com/york/york200507121626.asp

----

Here is some more interesting reading material http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/005/804yqqnr.asp?pg=2

"The Mother of All Connections"

Different subject, but involves another "myth" - the "no connections between Al Qaeda and Iraq"......



skye
July 14, 2005   04:53 PM PDT
 


Former Ambassador Wilson is calling for Rove to step down.

Am I the only one who finds this humorous?
Jamie
July 14, 2005   08:31 PM PDT
 
No, you aren't the only one. You are one of millions.
skye
July 14, 2005   11:42 PM PDT
 
Wolf Blitzer: But the other argument that's been made against you is that you've sought to capitalize on this extravaganza, having that photo shoot with your wife, who was a clandestine officer of the CIA, and that you've tried to enrich yourself writing this book and all of that.
What do you make of those accusations, which are serious accusations, as you know, that have been leveled against you.

Joe Wilson: My wife was not a clandestine officer the day that Bob Novak blew her identity."

Hat tip: RightWing News.
Chris of Dangerous Logic
July 19, 2005   09:11 AM PDT
 
Joe Wilson lied - Saddam tried!
Right Thinking Girl
July 21, 2005   12:48 PM PDT
 
I love this post. The Plame affair has fascinated me since it was first exposed and I can not, for the life of me, find a shred of evidence that there is anything of substance in the whole mess. I love Joe Wilson though, I really do. He's hilarious. Every time he opens his mouth, his indicts himself.
gunnyg
August 11, 2005   07:06 AM PDT
 
Just go to Right Wing News and you'll see some leftist morons STILL mewling about Rovegate. It was a flash-in-the-pan but the left got all wound up on it. Typical.

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments