|
The following is a copy of the email I sent to the Sci-Fi channel.Last night, I watched the season premiere of Battlestar Galactica, and, I have to say, was thoroughly disgusted. The writers of the show have taken its previous anti-war, anti-Bush undertone to an entirely new level. The entire episode was nothing more than a justification of terrorism committed by some of the main characters, and I'm surprised and saddened that you would allow such a thing to air on your channel.UPDATE: Psycho Toddler put it so much more eloquently than I. |
| Name October 7, 2006 12:09 PM PDT Good observation . I was thinking the same thing as I watched the show. Pity, I used to enjoy it , but now unfortunately I will no longer. | ||
| SalGal October 7, 2006 06:37 PM PDT Another poison pen pal... Go Cav! | ||
| rightwingprof October 9, 2006 10:18 AM PDT I think you're reading things into the show that aren't there. <a href="http://rightwingnation.com/index.php/2006/10/08/2172/">See here</a>. | ||
| Jim October 9, 2006 12:26 PM PDT Rightwingprof is a nutjob. After looking at his website, I want to ask...is "Birth of a Nation" just a film? People write things and make movies and TV shows for a reason. You don't have an episode like that without trying to glorify the bad guys. | ||
| CavalierX October 10, 2006 05:34 AM PDT >I think you're reading things into >the show that aren't there. Not at all. "I think the allegory has moved on with us. The series deals with the aftermath of 9/11 and the war on terror, the Iraq war, the war in Afghanistan – it’s imbued with things that are more current, like liberty versus freedom. Security versus freedom. The ideas of how far a society is willing to go in order to safeguard its citizens, what happens in witch trials or how the does the judicial process become a witch trial? What does it mean when you have a prisoner and you put his head in a bucket and you tell him he’s going to drown to get information out of him? Those are things happening in the world and those are things that we tackled on Galactica. This is what we do. This show is about the experience we’re having right now and trying to view that experience through the prism of science fiction. Not necessarily to make it ripped from today’s headlines, but essentially to take the themes and ideas of what is happening in the world and put them in this format and examine them from a different light and perspective." - Ron Moore, writer/producer of Battlestar Galactica SFX Magazine interview, 10 May 2005 | ||
| Irish Diablo October 11, 2006 11:10 AM PDT The new Battlestar Galactica sucks big, hairy, dirty elephant balls! If making the Cylons human-looking wasn't bad enough, they made Starbuck a woman. WTF is that? The wirters, producers and the Sci-Fi channel should all burn in hell for that blasphemous piece of Bantha poodoo. | ||
| psychotoddler October 18, 2006 12:22 PM PDT Great post, great letter. Moral equivalence is again the main issue. This is a direct descendant of Political Correctness. If you are unable to acurately label things, you can't address them in an intelligent fashion. Terrorism is reprehensible. But rebellion may not be. The Occupation of the Warsaw Ghetto was evil with no good intentions. The purpose of that occupation was to control the Jewish population so they could be gradually deported and murdered. Period. The uprising against it was admirable and totally correct. To portray the Cylons as being the equivalents of the Nazis during WW2, but then compare those that fight against them to the Islamofascists who blow up civilians because they want to maintain their own rule of terror in the region and play to our press is flawed, and it tells me that the producers can't tell the difference between Nazis whose ultimate goal is genocide, and Americans, whose only interest in the region is altruistic and would be more than happy to get the hell out of there when the population can behave itself. Nevertheless, I'm still not ready to abandon BSG. I think there's still room for hope. | ||
| Christopher Taylor October 28, 2006 06:32 PM PDT And here I thought the only reason the new Battlestar Galactica is because they turned it into a soap opera and got rid of the cool looking chrome Cylons | ||
| Leave a Comment: |